Planning a Crime: How to Outline Your Mystery Novel
I’m a planner. Organizing my novels is no different. I typically outline my stories before the first draft. Outlines help me stay organized and keep track of the plot, characters, settings, my research, and everything in between. So, how do you outline your mystery novel?
Not everyone outlines or plans their novels. However, I’m a firm believer in keeping notes. When writing a mystery novel that’s crime-centric, keeping track of everything is a must for me.
It took me a while to find an outlining method I liked for planning my mystery stories. However, I found one particular way for me to play out the mystery, thus helping me plan out the crime and story overall.
I rely on the five W questions (plus their friend): who, what, where, when, why, and how.

Who?
“Who” can mean a lot of different things and it never hurts to write all of it down. The “who” refers to the characters within your story. When writing any genre, there are many people to keep track of.
In the mystery genre, your characters can play a plethora of roles. Take a list of your characters (that you have planned so far) and line them up. Then, assign them jobs by asking yourself a few questions.
- Who is the protagonist? Who is the antagonist?
- Who are the investigators? Who are the victims?
- Who are the suspects? Who are the culprits?
- Who are the witnesses? Who discovered the crimes?
- Who are the accomplices? Who are the passersby?
Do you need absolutely all these jobs to be filled to write your novel? Probably not. Take what questions you need and leave what you don’t. But maybe keep them in your back pocket in case you need them for later.
Also, characters may also fit into multiple roles. For example, the witness is also a suspect who may or may not also be the culprit or accomplice in disguise.
Alternatively, you might have a plan for a character, but they decide they want something different as you write. When writing The Perfect Alibi, my initial plan had the protagonist be the detective and POV character. Fast forward to a few drafts later, and his assistant is actually the POV character and more of a lead role than the detective.
What?
You may not know the “what” right away. However, depending on what you already know about your novel (plot ideas, for example), you can answer some “what” questions.
- What happened? What are the major and minor plot points?
- What’s the crime? What’s the problem or the secret?
- What was the culprit’s plan?
- What is the weapon? What’s stolen? (Depending on whether your crime is a murder or robbery or something else. Adapt the question as needed.)
- What’s the motive?
These are important questions that need to be answered throughout the novel during the investigation process. Also, a motive is everything for nabbing the culprit.
Again, these are questions you don’t need to know right away. However, it’s good to have somewhat of an idea. This way, you can start gluing the pieces together as you write.

Where?
Like any other novel, the “where” is important. There are a lot of different places your investigator needs to go in order to solve the crime and they want to take your readers along with them. So, where do you need to go?
- Where does the overall story take place? (Is it based on an actual place or fictional?)
- Where are the major places of the story? (Police station, investigator’s office, etc.)
- Where was the crime discovered, or where did the crime take place? (In case you’re writing about a murder and the body was moved to throw investigators off the trail.)
- Where were the weapons or items stolen?
- Where was the culprit hiding?
- Where were the witnesses? Where was the victim(s)?
- Where was your investigator when the crime took place?
When?
Timing is everything with solving a mystery. Crimes are time-sensitive to the investigators. Knowing the “when” of it all is crucial to your characters being able to solve the problem. Also, time will wrap everything nicely by the end. You want your novel to make sense, after all.
- When does the overall story take place?
- When did the crime take place? When was the crime discovered?
- When are the clues and evidence discovered?
- When does the culprit get caught?
- How long does the overall investigation take?
Why?
Do you remember I said earlier that your culprit needs to have a motive? The “why” is what drives your plot and your story forward. If there’s no “why” to anything that happens, then… Why do your readers care about the story and its characters? Why would they want to read it?
- Why did the culprit commit the crime? Why did the culprit choose the victim?
- Why was your investigator the best one to solve the crime?
- Why did the crime take so long (or so little) to solve?
Basically, make sure you know the reasoning behind the story. All stories matter and deserve to be told. However, you also want to express to your readers why yours matters most.

How?
Similar to the points above, “how” is another key factor your readers need to know. The “why” is the driving force behind it all, but the “how” explains that driving force being carried out.
- How did the culprit pull off their crime?
- How did the culprit get caught?
- How did the investigator figure it out?
Outlining your mystery novel doesn’t have to be a chore
Some of these questions you don’t need to answer, especially not right away. Some questions are redundant from others, but I always find it helpful to write things down a few times to remember. Also, these questions might lead to more questions.
This is something that’s great for any genre. Figuring out the who, what, where, when, why, and how is key to any story’s plot planning. These particular questions cater to the mystery genre, but you can alter the questions to fit your idea’s needs.
How do you put this outline together?
I like to write it all down in a notebook or in a separate notes section on Scrivener. You can choose to add these notes anywhere you want. To help get you started, I created a free printable workbook (with more questions) for you to use. Click the button below to get it from my Ko-fi shop.
Let's Chat!
How do you go about planning crimes in your novels? Do you have other questions you’d ask and answer?
Let me know your thoughts in the comments below.


Rachel Poli
Author
Rachel Poli is a cozy fiction author, typically exploring cozy mystery, cozy fantasy, and visionary fiction. She writes short stories, novels, and the occasional flash fiction piece.
Her work explores the obscurities of life through themes of love, loss, and mental health. These stories unleash genuine emotion that will leave you with deep thoughts.
In her spare time, she's usually organizing something or playing video games with a coffee in hand. She lives in New England with her zoo.