7 Reasons I Ditched Goodreads and Switched to The StoryGraph
I’ve been in a reading slump for a long time. I go in spurts with reading where I binge read a bunch of books and then I stop reading entirely for a year. When I try to get back into it, I reread my favorite series, Warriors by Erin Hunter.
I’m not one to keep up with trending books. I rarely read what everyone else is reading. If I do, it’s not for another year or two; long after the book was popular.
I often stayed up to date with books and added to my ever-growing TBR pile through Goodreads. That was my way of staying active; buying books and allowing them to collect dust on my shelves, or adding books to my TBR that would eventually be buried down the list and forgotten.
Then I discovered The StoryGraph, and I looked at books differently.

What is Goodreads?
I’m pretty sure everyone knows what Goodreads is, but I’ll explain anyway.
Goodreads is a book catalog where registered users can keep track of their reading progress, add books to their TBR piles, find recommendations, and connect with like-minded readers and their favorite authors. Oh, and it’s owned by Amazon since 2013.
Honestly, I think that’s when it started going downhill. It was gradual, and I didn’t think there were any other options like Goodreads. So, like many of us, I’m sure, I sucked it up. I still used Goodreads for a while.
I used it to track my reading progress, keep a TBR list, keep tabs on some of my favorite authors, connected with blogger friends, and used its well-known yearly reading challenge.
Until I came across an ad for The StoryGraph.
What is The StoryGraph?
The StoryGraph is an online book catalog where registered users can keep track of their books, TBR piles, and reading progress. It has reading challenges, including a yearly one, personalized recommendations, and you can connect with like-minded readers.
Sounds similar to Goodreads, right? It is, but I think it’s better. So, let’s get into it.

Why I switched to The StoryGraph
Despite the two platforms being similar, there are still quite a few differences in functionality and aesthetics. Overall, I think The StoryGraph wins out, but it might not be for everyone.
The StoryGraph is cleaner
Upon going onto the Goodreads homepage, you’re greeted with some of your stats on the left side, but the focus is what everyone else is reading and reviewing. It looks more like a social media platform and, honestly, I’m sick of the social media grind. I want to catalog my books and discuss shared favorite stories with others. I don’t really care to see what they’re currently reading at the moment or what page number they’re on. At least, I don’t want to see that upon immediately going on the website. I’d rather that be its own separate page.
The StoryGraph has its own Community tab set apart from the homepage. There, you can see the status updates of what others are reading and where they are in their current reads. It also goes deeper than simple reading updates.
You can view buddy reads, readalongs, and book clubs. Similar to groups on Goodreads, but they’re set up in a cleaner way. The page has less to look at, thus it’s less overwhelming.
There are no ads on The StoryGraph
Piggybacking off of the fact that The StoryGraph has an overall cleaner look than Goodreads, Goodreads is riddled with ads. Upon going on the homepage, you’re greeted with a huge banner of an ad with more ads on the sidebar. This is on all pages of Goodreads.
Not only does it slow the website down, but it looks ugly. I can’t remember if this site had so many ads before Amazon bought it, but why does a huge company like Amazon need so many ads on one website?
The ads are the reason I stopped using the Goodreads website all together. I only went on the app since the ads are less in your face. However, the app is cluttered and can sometimes be slow, as well.

The StoryGraph has a free plan and paid plan
I don’t pay for The StoryGraph. Maybe someday I will help support it since it’s still a smaller platform, but the paid option is there. This sounds like a negative for The StoryGraph and a positive for Goodreads since that platform is 100% free.
In a way, it is. However, the paid option of The StoryGraph allows the website to stay ad-free, which is a plus in my book. The free version still allows you full access to all the features without gatekeeping anything behind a paywall.
With that said, why would you pay? Well, you’d help keep the website ad-free and get extra customizable perks for your stats.
Again, I don’t have The StoryGraph Plus; I still only have the free version. So, I can’t speak too much about it. I appreciate there’s an option to support the smaller platform that doesn’t withhold any major features to those who can’t afford to upgrade their plan.
The StoryGraph has fun stats
Speaking stats, you get stats on The StoryGraph with fun, colorful charts! Goodreads has stats, too, but it’s mostly for your “year in books.”
The Goodreads stats show how many books or pages you read within one year or within all time. However, some of these are hard to read.
I much prefer the stats on The StoryGraph for a few reasons.
First, the stats come in colorful pie charts and bar graphs. (It’s no secret I love color coding!)
For example, there’s a pie chart based on the mood of books you typically read. For me, I apparently read a lot of books that are reflective, hopeful, and emotional. Other charts include pacing of books (whether you read more fast-paced books), fiction versus nonfiction, which formats you favor, and more.
Bar graphs include how many books you’ve read by an author, the genres you read in most often, and a breakdown of books and pages read per month.
The stats also show how many books and pages you’ve read within the year and the average time you to finish a book.
If you pay for the Plus plan, you can customize these charts with your own colors and even make your own charts. For example, if you wanted to keep track of how many books you read with blue covers, you can make a chart of cover colors. (At least, I think that’s how it would work to my understanding. Again, I don’t pay for the Plus plan so I’m not entirely sure.)
Finally, you can turn on the “streak” option in your account settings. If you read every day and update it on the website, The StoryGraph will show a fire icon with a number. I love visually seeing that I’ve been consistent with reading.
The StoryGraph has more reading challenges
Goodreads has the yearly reading challenge where you pledge to read a certain amount of books within the calendar year. I think that challenge is great, and it has gotten me out of a few reading slumps in the past. I love a good competition, even though it’s not actually a competition.
The StoryGraph has that challenge as well, but there are also many other challenges. The website itself has its own set of challenges, such as the Onboarding challenge, which encourages you to use the website’s features while reading. For example, read a book that the website recommended to you or read a book that’s currently in a buddy read.
Users can create their own challenges, too, and other users can join in. It’s an added way to bring the community of readers together.

Recommendations on The StoryGraph are more accurate
Over the years, I noticed Goodreads pushed the more “popular” books rather than books I would actually read. Of course, this doesn’t mean that I wouldn’t like those books. It’s always good to read outside your comfort zone and broaden your horizons a bit.
However, the recommendations were always similar books by the same authors over and over. I’d go to the Lists sections to look up books in my preferred genres and even then, most of those lists (curated by users) would have the same books by the same authors.
The StoryGraph takes your stats into account. I have found more new books with being on The StoryGraph in one year than I ever have with my many years on Goodreads.
I’m not saying Goodreads’s recommendations aren’t good, but they simply weren’t for me. I’ve had better luck finding new books and authors on The StoryGraph.
Bonus perk: reviewing books
I’m not too picky with reviewing books. Everyone reviews books uniquely, especially since no two readers read the same book.
With that said, on Goodreads, when writing a review you’re able to add your start and end dates, write a brief review (or a long one) and give it a star rating on a scale from one to five.
The StoryGraph does the same thing, but it’s a bit more guided. So, if you don’t know what to write for a review or you’re new to reviewing books, you can fill in the form and let that be your review.
In addition, your answers on that form get added to the book stats. When someone comes across the book on the platform, it’ll show the percentage of readers who thought the book was more plot-driven versus character-driven, for example.
The form asks you to check off different moods (or tones) the book has, what the pacing is like, and more. It also leaves room for you to add potential triggers or content warnings.
I appreciate how detailed it is. You have the option to answer the form and give it a rating, or you can skip all that, write your own review and rating, or simply give it a rating. It’s totally up to you.

One more thing to note
The StoryGraph is a catalog for readers. Goodreads is a catalog for readers and a platform for authors. When you join Goodreads, you can join as an author and add your book to their database. Also, you have your own blog and can answer questions from readers. All the while, you keep track of your own reading.
Meanwhile, The StoryGraph is only for readers. When you join, you sign up as you would any other platform and log your reading. You can’t add books to the system regardless of them being yours or not. Everyone’s a reader and that’s that.
So, if you’re an author looking for another platform to add your book to, you won’t find that on The StoryGraph. However, if you’re an avid reader and want to join a community of like-minded bookworms, then The StoryGraph is a great place to be.
The StoryGraph is better than Goodreads
I’m not deleting my Goodreads account, but I’m not active on there anymore. To be honest, it’s a little sad because it was a great platform. I met some cool people there.
However, over time, Goodreads got progressively worse for me. The ads clogged up the pages; it slowed things down, and the recs seemed to always gravitate toward what’s popular and trending, not necessarily what I was interested in.
As of right now, The StoryGraph is still a relatively small platform. At least, it’s small compared to Goodreads. But that’s one thing I like about it. It’s clean, not cluttered, and I don’t have a million of other people’s updates in my face.
Now, I’m not sponsored by The StoryGraph, affiliated, or associated with them. I just really enjoy the platform. The StoryGraph has a calmer vibe to it and that’s what I really love about it. I think The StoryGraph is what helped me get out of my year-long reading slump.
Let's Chat!
How you heard of The StoryGraph? If so, are you on there and what do you think of it?
Let me know your thoughts in the comments below.


Rachel Poli
Author
Rachel Poli is a cozy fiction author, typically exploring cozy mystery, cozy fantasy, and visionary fiction. She writes short stories, novels, and the occasional flash fiction piece.
Her work explores the obscurities of life through themes of love, loss, and mental health. These stories unleash genuine emotion that will leave you with deep thoughts.
In her spare time, she's usually organizing something or playing video games with a coffee in hand. She lives in New England with her zoo.