Amazon Affiliate Notice
This post contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, I earn commission from qualifying purchases.

Series: The Redemption Detective Agency, book 1
Publisher: Love-Based Publishing on October 15, 2024
Genres: Fiction, Cozy Mystery
Format: eBook
Page Count: 177
FTC Disclaimer: I received an advance review copy for free from the author via BookSirens, and I am leaving this review voluntarily. All opinions are honest and my own.
Blurb from Amazon
When life gives you lemons, make lemonade. Or maybe a gin and tonic.
Emily Hildebrandt has run into a bit of a rough patch. She’s lost her job, her fiance and her apartment. Still, she never expected to be desperate enough to accept an invitation to live with her eccentric Aunt Tilde in Redemption, Wisconsin.
But, beggars can’t be choosers. Even if part of the deal is she has to pretend to work at her aunt’s latest hair-brained scheme, The Redemption Detective Agency.
Seriously, the woman is a retired nurse. Why does she think she’s remotely qualified to run a detective agency, especially in a creepy little town like Redemption?
But, when a strange phone call suddenly thrusts them into an actual case, Emily finds herself hoping her aunt really does know what she’s doing … or an innocent person may be the one to suffer the consequences.
Review
The Mysterious Case of the Missing Motive is the first book I’ve read from this author and she didn’t disappoint. I do enjoy a good cozy mystery where the protagonist accidentally gets thrown into solving a case. What made this story unique was that the case was already closed, and the culprit was already in jail. I won’t say more to avoid spoilers, but I liked the approach.
My biggest issue with the book was some of the characters. The older women (Aunt Tiled and Mildred) were so overbearing. They grew on me by the end, but I found them to be too overwhelming, especially in the beginning. They didn’t make a good first impression on me.
The protagonist, Emily, was okay. She’s down on her luck and has a right to be bitter at times, but her lack of confidence in her looks drove me bananas. It’s a trope I’ve seen a lot in cozy mysteries where the female protagonist compares herself to a “perfect-looking” woman and I feel that type of description is simply not needed. Unless the lack of confidence has something to do with their personality and growth by the end, it’s an overused personality trait for the supposed “strong female lead.”
Overall, The Mysterious Case of the Missing Motive was well written, easy to follow along, and an interesting approach to solving a murder. I enjoyed my time with this story even if the characters sometimes made me roll my eyes. Regardless, I’ll look forward to book two.
Overall Score

Rachel Poli
Author
Rachel Poli is a cozy fiction author, typically exploring cozy mystery, cozy fantasy, and visionary fiction. She writes short stories, novels, and the occasional flash fiction piece.
Her work explores the obscurities of life through themes of love, loss, and mental health. These stories unleash genuine emotion that will leave you with deep thoughts.
In her spare time, she's usually organizing something or playing video games with a coffee in hand. She lives in New England with her zoo.


Book Reviews are OPEN for 2026
Are you an author who recently published a book? Or do you need help with your upcoming book launch?
Visit my Book Review Policy to learn more.
I look forward to reading your work.

HI Rachel, a great review. I also like cozy mysteries from time-to-time.
Yes, I enjoy cozies a lot and have been trying to broaden the authors I read. Thanks for reading.
My pleasure. My favourite cozy author is still Agatha Christie. She was so clever.
Agatha Christie will always remain top tier!
Yes, she is the Queen