A Toast to The Perfect Alibi

A Toast to The Perfect Alibi

If you’ve been following my blog for a long time, then The Perfect Alibi probably sounds familiar to you. It was the first book in a softboiled detective novel series starring George Florence and Lilah Williams. I began working on the first book (and the series as a whole) in roughly 2011. Now it’s 2026, so what happened to it?

It Began in a Notebook

One random Saturday morning, my sister and I decided to go to Barnes & Noble, sit at the café, and get some writing done. It turned into a routine. Some weeks, we’d bring our laptops and write. Other weeks we’d handwrite in notebooks. Of course, there were some times we’d bring our work and chit-chat or browse for books instead.

There was one Saturday when I didn’t know what to write. I brought a new notebook with me and decided to start with a clichéd line: “It was a dark and stormy night.” Except I added to it.

“It was a dark and stormy night, and I was wet.”

Thus, the bumbling detective–deemed George–was born.

Yes, originally George was a “bumbling detective” a la Pink Panther style. His name “George” was the first male name that popped into my head. I think I compared him to George Costanza from Seinfeld.

As time went on, his character grew enough that I thought to give him a last name. We sat beside the traveling section at Barnes & Noble and there was a brochure for Florence, Italy.

George Florence. It had a nice ring to it.

A Tale of One Thousand Drafts

At the time, I didn’t have anything published other than random short stories and flash fiction on my blog. Writing The Perfect Alibi–which wasn’t even the title at the time–was pretty much my first “real” novel.

I had worked on novels in the past, writing 50,000 words and more due to NaNoWriMo. I did complete some novels, but never got past the editing stage. The Perfect Alibi was the first novel idea I took seriously. The first novel I wanted to complete, polish, and publish.

My problem was, I needed The Perfect Alibi to be perfect.

I Had No Idea What I Was Doing

NaNoWriMo allowed me to make excellent progress on The Perfect Alibi. Aside from what I wrote in my notebook, I completed the first draft of the novel through that writing challenge. And every year NaNoWriMo (or a Camp NaNo session) would occur, I’d rewrite the novel again.

And again. And again.

Why? Because editing intimidated me. I also had no idea what I was looking for when editing my work, so my “edits” were essentially me reading through the draft and fixing typos here and there. Then I’d rewrite the draft to make the changes and input any new ideas I got while editing.

Not the best course of action, but you live and learn, right?

Every draft came with a new outline. Every outline came with more notes. I had many folders, multiple notebooks, plus countless drafts on Microsoft Word. (Yeah, it wasn’t until years into writing this book that I finally got Scrivener to have everything in one place.)

Cue the Writers Group

In early 2015 I joined a writers group at my local library. I didn’t submit The Perfect Alibi right away because I didn’t think it was “ready” for others to read. In November 2015, I met up with some people from the NaNoWriMo regional forums and invited them to join the writers group. Shortly after they joined, I realized the writers group is supposed to help me and my writing and my books.

So I submitted one chapter of The Perfect Alibi every month, receiving feedback from five amazing other writers. And even though the draft I had submitted to them was probably draft ten or something like that, they were all in agreement about one thing: the third-person POV from George did not work.

Three POV Changes

When I first began working on this novel, I wrote it in first-person POV through George’s eyes. It was a difficult thing to do for a few reasons. One, I’m not a fan of first-person. So, why I chose to write in that POV, I have no idea. And two, I’m not a man. Writing from the perspective of a man wasn’t easy. 

So, I changed it to third-person through George’s eyes. Yes, I went back and forth between limited and omniscient. It wasn’t great, okay?

I don’t remember how many drafts I wrote and rewrote of that novel, changing the POVs trying to get the voice to sound right before my writers group said, “Lilah wants the spotlight.”

I gave it a go. I rewrote the next few chapters in Lilah’s third-person limited POV. I gave them to my writers group and we were all in agreement. The story sounded much better.

Thus, it was time to rewrite the manuscript. Again.

More Drafts Equaled More Ideas

The longer I stayed with these characters, the more things changed. I’m talking about the plot, the murder, my narrative style, and, of course, sequels. I even began working on the second book at one point because I didn’t want to edit The Perfect Alibi anymore. I had been working on it for years and did countless rewrites; I was ready to move onto the next mystery.

Through all this, more ideas surfaced to the point that I began lightly outlining and planning the series. At one point, I had about ten novel ideas for this cast of characters, including short story collections and a novella.

Essentially, even though I had been working on this novel for years, I was mostly talk and not much action. I thought the more I wrote, the easier it would get. Editing would be a breeze and, because it had been years in the making, surely it was one thousand times better than the original first draft, right? An agent would scoop it up!

Yeah… no.

Six Years Later

When I pursued writing full time in mid 2017, I finally began taking my novel seriously. I was working in the industry and had learned more about the creative writing process. Not to mention there was an uptick in self-publishing and that looked like a viable option for me.

I started outlining differently. I took better notes about my story. I planned my mystery’s crime in a unique way that helped me lay out clues and evidence for my characters. I tracked clues, evidence, statements, and everything in between throughout the novel. 

I was way more organized and there seemed to be more thought behind these ideas.

I had a self-publishing goal. I had done the research, learned more about the process, and was taking actionable steps to get there.

My manuscripts for The Perfect Alibi were no longer “draft one,” “draft one again,” “draft one rewritten,” and so on. Every draft had its own purpose. My edits in between drafts were cohesive and had actual developmental edits or solid revisions. I made margin notes to fact-check, rearrange paragraphs or chapters, etc.

I was finally making actual progress.

When Math and Writing Don’t Mix

Everything was going well with the novel, even though I didn’t always feel like I was making good progress. Between editing The Perfect Alibi into the ground, planning out the series, and ensuring I didn’t dig myself into various plot holes, I worked diligently up until I ran into a snag.

In 2022, I realized some timeline issues. You see, in The Perfect Alibi, some events that occur in the present are due to actions from the past. I decided to screw around with time and create a complicated past/present situation in the novel. There’s a good reason for it, I’m not taking it out. However, since it needs to stay, I had some math to do.

The timeline was complicated, and not just for The Perfect Alibi, but for everything I built for the series.

I needed to create a timeline of events for The Perfect Alibi, and for events that occurred before the book.

It spiraled, as I typically do, and tried expanding the timeline into the sequel and so on. It was all necessary. These were all things I’d need to know at some point, and I tried my best to configure the series, even before the events of book one.

But math won. I’m not great with math, and I kept digging myself into a deep hole when it came to the characters’ ages. (For example, George was meant to be in his 30s. With the way things worked out, he would have had to graduate from the police academy at eighteen or something like that. Not exactly realistic, even for fiction.)

Enter 2023

I had been working on this for months. I couldn’t figure it out, and I was feeling discouraged about the plots I had woven together. Did I have too many moving pieces? Were there too many characters? Was there some form of mathematical equation I just couldn’t quite figure out?

I realize most of this doesn’t make much sense to you, but… I can’t explain further or else it’d be spoilers. Yes, I do still plan on completing and releasing The Perfect Alibi at some point.

When? I don’t know. Because in early 2023, I decided to step back from the project and work on something else. I knew I needed a break, and that’s why I’m writing this blog post.

It’s Been Three Years

Not too long ago, I was looking through my Scrivener projects when I came across The Perfect Alibi. That’s when I noticed the date of when the document was last modified.

March 4, 2023.

Originally, I intended to take a step back from the series for a month or two. I don’t know what happened, but overtime, I just forgot about The Perfect Alibi entirely. And I don’t mean I didn’t think about the characters now and then, but thinking about going back to the project filled me with dread.

Honestly, I’ve thought about starting from scratch again, but I’ve done that so many times that it wouldn’t make sense to do that. So, I just never went back to it. I kept putting it off.

If you asked me today when I last worked on the novel, and I didn’t see that date, I probably would have told you that I worked on it sometime last year. Time is utterly lost on me, and the fact that three years have passed since I’ve worked with George and Lilah completely boggles my mind.

It’s Bittersweet

When I first realized how much time had passed, I was sad; disappointed in myself. It’s unlikely your “first” novel will ever see the light of day, but I was so determined that George and Lilah would be my “big” idea. They’d get my foot in the publishing door. Those characters would be beside me when I officially became an author. 

But then I realized just how much I’ve accomplished between spring 2023 and now.

  • I released a second edition of Sunday Morning.
  • I wrote and published a duology of short story collections.
  • I rebranded myself as an author, and gave my website a makeover.
  • I started a Ko-fi page for my writing, and began treating my creative writing as a business.
  • I got a certificate in writing for video games, learning new skills, and improving the way I tell stories.

I didn’t realize it at the time, but George and Lilah were the ones that got me my start. They’re the characters that helped me hone my skills. That story is what shaped the way I write mysteries. That series is how I’ve learned what to do and what not to do when it comes to varying stages of the book creation process.

For years, I classified The Perfect Alibi as a cozy mystery, when it most certainly is not. In a weird way, that story helped me realize the difference between softboiled detective fiction (what it actually is) and what a cozy mystery is. Thus, I’ve been able to better recognize what I need to do and how I should write the Perk Up series. (And yes, that’s an actual cozy mystery series.)

Will The Perfect Alibi Come Back?

I’m sure it’s no coincidence that I lost my job two months prior to me halting operations on The Perfect Alibi. Despite being stuck for so long, I was probably in more of a depressive state than I remember. I probably stopped working on that novel because trying to figure out math seemed like a silly thing to do when I needed to get my life and career back on track.

Over the past three years, I’ve discovered more about myself. I’ve found a more confident version of my writing voice and style. I have three published books under my belt, I have an official author logo, I’ve learned so much more about the cozy mystery genre, my writing in general has improved, and I’ve learned so many fascinating new things about storytelling and various mediums of storytelling.

I don’t think any of that would have happened if I didn’t stop working on The Perfect Alibi.

That said, The Perfect Alibi will get its time.

That story introduced a lot for me in terms of learning about the industry, meeting other writers on and offline, and gave me way more practice writing than any one person could possibly need in their lifetime.

The Perfect Alibi taught me how to find my writing voice and my writing style.

Publishing Sunday Morning taught me that I have the confidence and the means to be an author.

The Grim Reaper Files taught me to be who I am, and to keep writing for myself.

Now I’m working on the Perk Up series because it’s the genre I’ve always wanted to write: cozy mystery. I’m writing the story that’s always been meant to be, but I wasn’t ready at the time.

I’m Not Giving up on George and Lilah

In a few years, when Perk Up is complete and published, I’ll be ready to revisit George and Lilah. Those characters will have their time in the spotlight. Out of all the stories I’ve written, The Perfect Alibi certainly deserves publication the most.

It may not be for another decade, but George and Lilah are my babies and they deserve to be written by an established writer. So, when I have more experience under my belt, and their story is ready to be told, it will be told.

Let's Chat!

Do you remember The Perfect Alibi? Has there ever been a story you worked on for so long and so hard only for it to get pushed to the side?

Let me know your thoughts in the comments below.

Rachel Poli

Rachel Poli

Author

Rachel Poli is a cozy fiction author, typically exploring cozy mystery, cozy fantasy, and visionary fiction. She writes short stories, novels, and the occasional flash fiction piece.

Her work explores the obscurities of life through themes of love, loss, and mental health. These stories unleash genuine emotion that will leave you with deep thoughts.

In her spare time, she's usually organizing something or playing video games with a coffee in hand. She lives in New England with her zoo.

Website | Ko-fi | All Links

error: This content is copyrighted by Rachel Poli. You may not select, copy, or use any of this material.